Recent acts of extreme violence perpetrated by some Muslims—ranging from targeted murders to silence critics of the Quran to mass atrocities committed by groups like ISIS—prompt a critical question: how do Islam’s foundational texts, particularly the Quran and Hadith, address such behavior? High-profile events, such as the October 7 attacks, the campaigns of ISIS in Iraq and Syria, and conflicts in Sudan, have resulted in millions killed, raped, or enslaved, raising concerns about a recurring pattern of violence tied to Islamic theology. This article explores whether these acts reflect an aberration or a deeper continuity with the Quran’s portrayal of divine attributes and the documented actions of the Prophet Mohammed, as recorded in Islamic sacred writings.