Recent acts of extreme violence perpetrated by some Muslims—ranging from targeted murders to silence critics of the Quran to mass atrocities committed by groups like ISIS—prompt a critical question: how do Islam’s foundational texts, particularly the Quran and Hadith, address such behavior? High-profile events, such as the October 7 attacks, the campaigns of ISIS in Iraq and Syria, and conflicts in Sudan, have resulted in millions killed, raped, or enslaved, raising concerns about a recurring pattern of violence tied to Islamic theology. This article explores whether these acts reflect an aberration or a deeper continuity with the Quran’s portrayal of divine attributes and the documented actions of the Prophet Mohammed, as recorded in Islamic sacred writings.

One studying a religion cannot isolate the practices of its founders from the religion itself. No matter what later apologists claim in defense of that religion, it remains that what the founder practiced, how he interpreted the text, and how he used the text offer the most accurate description of that religion. In this light, there is one frankly troubling and undeniable pattern in the life of Mohammed: his systemic elimination of all critics for nothing except criticizing him. The implication of this for the modern world cannot be exaggerated.